International Surrogacy: Understanding the Legal Risks of Overseas Arrangements

By Mark Treacy

Associate

For many intended parents, international surrogacy offers a route to building a family where domestic options may be limited. However, foreign surrogacy arrangements often involve a complex interaction between UK law, the law of the country where the child is born, immigration requirements, and the process of securing legal parenthood in England and Wales.

Whilst a child may be born overseas and living with their intended parents, this does not automatically mean that English law will recognise those parents as the child’s legal parents. Foreign surrogacy arrangements can create significant legal, practical and immigration challenges, particularly where the laws of the country concerned differ markedly from those in England and Wales.

A recent Family Court decision, D & Anor v K (Illegal Chinese Commercial Surrogacy) [2026] EWFC 279, serves as a timely reminder that specialist legal advice should be sought before embarking on any international surrogacy journey.

Legal Position on Surrogacy in the UK

Surrogacy is legal in the UK and is regulated in a unique way. Briefly, the following applies:

  • Surrogacy agreements are not legally enforceable.
  • The surrogate who gives birth to the child is usually recognised as the child’s legal mother at birth.
  • If the surrogate is married or in a civil partnership, their spouse or civil partner may also acquire legal parenthood.
  • Intended parents must usually apply for a Parental Order to become the child’s legal parents.
  • Commercial surrogacy is prohibited and intended parents are only allowed to meet the surrogate’s reasonable expenses.

A Parental Order transfers legal parenthood from the surrogate (and any other legal parent) to the intended parent or parents.

Why International Surrogacy Can Create Additional Risks

Many prospective parents assume that if a surrogacy arrangement is lawful abroad, the UK courts will automatically recognise the outcome. Unfortunately, this is not the case.

Even where intended parents are recognised as legal parents overseas, English law may reach a different conclusion. Matters that frequently arise include:

  • Whether the surrogate’s consent is valid under UK law.
  • Whether payments made to the surrogate can be authorised by the English court.
  • The child’s nationality and immigration status.
  • Recognition of foreign birth certificates.
  • Whether the arrangement complied with local law.
  • Concerns about exploitation, coercion or lack of informed consent.

These issues can significantly delay or complicate the process of applying for a Parental Order in England.

The significance of the case of D & Anor v K [2026]

The recent case of D & Anor v K involved a married same-sex couple who entered into a commercial surrogacy arrangement in China. The arrangement was facilitated by an intermediary and involved payments of approximately £93,000. Surrogacy is unlawful in China, and the English court had serious concerns regarding the transparency of the arrangement and the safeguards available to the surrogate.

The Family Court ultimately granted a Parental Order because it was in the child’s lifelong welfare interests to do so. However, Mr Justice MacDonald expressed significant concern about several aspects of the arrangement, including:

  • The absence of independent legal advice for the surrogate.
  • A lack of transparency regarding payments.
  • Limited direct contact between the intended parents and the surrogate.
  • Contractual provisions linking payment to the handover of the child.
  • The fact that the arrangement was unlawful in the country where it took place.

The court made clear that the decision should not be interpreted as approval of unlawful international commercial surrogacy arrangements. Indeed, the judge emphasised that courts will not simply grant a Parental Order because a child is already living with intended parents. Each case will be scrutinised carefully, particularly where public policy concerns arise.

Concluding remarks

For intended parents considering surrogacy abroad, early specialist advice is not just advisable, it is essential. We can advise on all aspects of domestic and international surrogacy, including parental orders, legal parenthood, immigration considerations and cross-border family law issues. Obtaining advice at the planning stage can help identify potential obstacles before they become significant legal problems, enabling families to move forward with confidence.