Finding the Right Premises: Where Data Meets Gut Instinct – and the Legal Checks that Should Never be Overlooked

By Abbie McDonald

Associate

AI and data analytics are increasingly helping food and drink businesses identify the right location and premises for their next venture. From analysing footfall and local demographics to assessing competition and spending patterns, businesses have more information than ever to help them make informed decisions.

While AI and data can provide valuable insight, they should not be the sole basis for choosing a location. Understanding your customer base remains just as important. Who are your target customers? What are their spending habits, preferences and expectations? Does the location reflect the type of experience you want to offer? Footfall figures may look impressive, but they are of little value if the people passing your premises are not your potential customers. Sometimes, commercial instinct and first-hand knowledge of the local market can be just as valuable as the data itself.

However, finding the right location is only half the battle. Before committing to new premises, there are several important legal considerations:

1. Planning Permission and Permitted Use

Check that the premises can legally be used for your intended business.

Restaurants and cafés generally fall within Class E, whereas pubs, drinking establishments and hot food takeaways are generally classed as sui generis uses. This distinction matters, as a change of use may require planning permission, for example converting a shop into a hot food takeaway.

Additional permission may also be required for external alterations, signage or extraction systems, particularly if the premises are listed or within a conservation area.

Do not assume that a previous occupier’s use automatically gives you the right to operate in the same way.

2. Licensing Requirements

If you intend to sell alcohol or serve hot food and drink between 11pm and 5am, you will generally require the relevant premises licence. Licensing should always be investigated before committing to the lease.

If a premises licence already exists, do not simply assume that it will meet your requirements. You should investigate which activities it authorises, the permitted operating hours and any restrictions or conditions attached to the licence.

3. Understanding the Lease

A commercially attractive rent can sometimes disguise significant financial obligations elsewhere in the lease. Pay particular attention to:

  • Term: does the length of the lease reflect your business plans? A long lease may provide security, but it can also leave you committed to rent and other liabilities if the business does not perform as expected.
  • Break Clauses: can you bring the lease to an end early, and what conditions must be satisfied? Even a relatively minor failure to comply can put the right to terminate at risk.
  • Rent Reviews: how and when can the rent increase? Is the review linked to open market rent, inflation, turnover or another mechanism?
  • Security of Tenure: will the lease benefit from the protection of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, giving qualifying business tenants a right to renew their tenancy when it expires?
  • Assignment and underletting:if you later wish to sell the business or move premises, will you be able to assign the lease or sublet? What landlord consents will be required?

4. Repairing Obligations and Alterations

Many commercial leases are granted on a full repairing and insuring (FRI) basis. For food and drink businesses, this can be particularly significant, as kitchens, extraction systems, drainage, plumbing and ventilation can be expensive to maintain or replace.

A tenant taking on an older property may also inherit responsibility for existing defects, depending on the lease wording. Consider obtaining a building survey and agreeing a schedule of condition to help limit your repairing obligations.

You should also establish whether the premises can accommodate your specialist equipment and whether any required alterations are permitted under the lease. Landlord’s consent to alterations will typically be required.   

Finally, consider your potential dilapidations liability at the end of the term, including any obligation to remove alterations and reinstate the premises.

5. Additional Costs, Compliance and Legal Restrictions

When assessing affordability, it is important to look beyond the monthly rent and investigate business rates, insurance contributions, service charges, VAT, rent deposits, personal guarantees and Stamp Duty Land Tax, where applicable.

Other compliance matters should also be investigated, including asbestos surveys and management responsibilities, the Energy Performance Certificate and fire safety requirements.

A solicitor will also need to investigate the property title for restrictions, rights of access and other matters that could affect how you operate.

Conclusion: the right premises need to work legally as well as commercially

Data, technology and commercial instinct can help identify an excellent location, but they cannot replace proper legal due diligence. A successful food and drink business needs premises that are legally suitable, physically fit for purpose and supported by lease terms that work for the business.

Involving a commercial property solicitor at an early stage can help identify potential problems, negotiate more favourable lease terms and avoid costly surprises further down the line.