Challenging Service Charge Costs

By Nicola Stewart

Senior Associate

In the recent case of Mr Mohammed Naeem and Russell Smith v Abacona Investments Limited [2026] UKUT 154 (LC), the Upper Tribunal were required to determine the challenged level of service charge costs sought by the landlord.  Of particular interest in this case was the Upper Tribunal’s consideration of whether alternative and cheaper methods could have been used.

Background

The case involved a property known as Endwood Court in Birmingham, which is a 1960s building containing 36 flats.

The landlord had undertaken external works in 2019 with the overall charge due from leaseholders in the region of £124,000.

A particular cost which caused concern for the leaseholders was the scaffolding cost of £75,000 as being unreasonably expensive and potentially unnecessary.   The leaseholders argued that more cost-effective methods of access were available.

The leaseholders identified that earlier works in 1992 had used roof cradles and for the 2019 works, roof cradles or scissor lifts could have been used by the landlord as a more cost-effective alternative to scaffolding.

The landlord’s position was that it was not appropriate to use the 1992 work methods as a comparison.

The leaseholders therefore challenged the service charge costs on the basis that they have not been reasonably incurred under s.19 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 (LTA 1985).  Pursuant to s.19 of the LTA 1985, the question for the First-Tier Tribunal (FTT) was whether the Landlord had acted reasonably in incurring the cost associated with the scaffolding.

The FTT found in favour of the landlord that the costs had been reasonably incurred and that the leaseholders had failed to show sufficient evidence that the use of the roof cradles or scissor lifts would have been a safe and appropriate method for the works in 2019.

The leaseholders appealed this decision.

The Upper Tribunal (UT) Decision

The permission to appeal was granted to the leaseholders on the basis that the FTT may not have applied the burden of proof correctly.  The leaseholders were required to provide evidence that the costs were unreasonable.  Once that threshold is met, the landlord would need to justify why such expenditure was reasonably incurred, when potentially cheaper alternatives may exist.

Whilst the UT considered that the FTT had not followed the correct analytical approach in respect of the burden of proof, the UT did not agree that the case should be remitted.

The specification of works in 2019 went beyond mere external decoration and included works of:

  • Repairs and replacement of timber window frames and sills.
  • Repairs to steel windows, including removal and realignment of window components.
  • Replacement of rotten timber.
  • Replacement of broken glazing.
  • Masonry and concrete repair work.

The UT concluded that such works required a stable platform and weather protection, which would not be provided by roof cradles or scissor lifts. Scaffolding and protective sheeting were appropriate and necessary for the scope of the works.

The UT also addressed the arguments raised by the leaseholder that the removal of the roof cradles was as a result of the landlord choosing to let the roof space for telecommunication equipment.   The UT noted that:

  • Before granting telecommunications leases, the landlord had consulted leaseholders.
  • Leaseholders had unanimously supported the landlord’s proposal.
  • Premiums and  income generated by the telecommunications leases had been applied for the benefit of leaseholders and the building, including contributions to service charge expenditure.

The leaseholders’ appeal was dismissed. 

The UT upheld the FTT’s decision that the costs, including the use of scaffolding had been reasonably incurred and were, therefore, recoverable through the service charge provisions of the leases.

Key Takeaway

Whilst each case will be determined on its own facts, the decision highlights two important service charge principles:

  1. Leaseholders need only establish that the costs appear unreasonable; the landlord then bears the burden of justifying the expenditure.
  2. Where major works involve substantial repair and replacement works, rather than straightforward decoration, tribunals may find that more expensive access arrangements such as scaffolding are reasonably required, even where cheaper alternatives are available.

If you need advice on service charges as a landlord or tenant, please contact us on 0345 646 0406 and a member of our team will be in touch.